Sous Rising: Eating Underground in Chicago

by Jessica Dixon
Print Email

sousrisingjakeUnderground dinners. Do you know about them?  Probably. I'm new to this: paprika still confuses me.

I first heard of this scene when eating at Elizabeth --an up and coming Chicago "farm to table" restaurant -- and learning that Chef/Owner Iliana Regan got her start in the underground restaurant world.

Call me fascinated, because her food was so good (e.g. stop what you're doing and try the carrot tea) that I found her by the bathroom and told her that her meal was the best I'd ever eaten. So that happened.

Being the daughter of a scientist, I took a very methodical approach to this whole underground thing. New Years day I set a goal to eat a secret dinner in 2013. I researched. Mastered back alley handshakes with dish boys. Nodded slowly and maintained uncomfortably long eye contact with sommeliers. Folded response notes into my fortune cookies. Got on some e-mail lists. You get the picture.

Which brings us to Sous Rising. Chef Jake Bickelhaupt has worked in famous kitchens around Chicago -- Alinea, Charlie Trotter's, Schwa. Now on Friday and Saturday nights, he and his charming wife Alexa open up their home to 8-10 guests, where he works his magic.

sousrising2One day before dinner you receive an e-mail with the location and 12-course BYO (bring your own alcohol) menu with pairing suggestions. He suggests starting the meal with white wine and finishing with red (which we did), split by a beer course of "dancing mushrooms", black garlic, and kumquat paired with Estrella Damm - a Catalan pilsner that took me right back to the cobbled streets of Barcelona. (We donated our extra Estrellas to the house).

When food makes me close my eyes, it's a good sign. All of the courses were good -- surprising and delightful to the eye, and combining unusual flavors to tell some sort of story. Some of them I will remember for a long time.

The first course -- "Kiwano", with jellied gin, tasted like an adult rosy gobstopper exploding in my mouth. Strong start. Jake handcrafted the tiny potato chips that accompanied a silky fingerling potato soup that ended far too soon.

My friend Rachel's favorite was Jake's comfort dish, "Winter Corn" -- corn in three ways, with an egg yolk you get to drop on top yourself (points for fun.) Then again, each subsequent course that came out was Rachel's favorite -- like the duck with hedgehog mushroom and black truffle, or the deconstructed carrot cake: lemon, chamomile, white chocolate and pistachio laid out in swirls.

sousrising3sousrising4

What was particularly fun about the Sous Rising meal, was witnessing an artist at work -- unencumbered by the reputation or style of a restaurant. He was in his home and he could cook how he wanted. As he was just over the counter, our table of 9 friendly and eclectic diners conversed with him throughout the meal.

"Jake, tell us why this beet tastes so good."

"Oh, I work on those for 24 hours. I cook them in this and then in something else." (Not a real quote.)

He actually told us what he did with the beets, but I didn't retain the information because I will never cook a beet for 24 hours.

Jake: your beets are beautiful. So is your wife. I wish you many happy secret dinners.

 

Jessica Dixon manages a physician practice in Chicago.  In her spare time she pursues aged goudas and adventures.

Comments   

+1 #6 brenda Athanus 2013-03-07 16:06
I love the whole concept of secret restaurants and have always had extraordinary food made with passion and love. I want to be on the mailing list, too! NOT
#5 Jessica Dixon 2013-03-05 16:38
@Alba: I was worried about cost myself, as a girl on a budget. As of the writing of this post, the Sous Rising dinner was $155, which I think was reasonable for 12 plates and the quality of the food. As for the pricing of other underground dinners, I couldnt betray the mystery. Mostly because I don't know.

I'm a pescatarian myself, and e-mailed Chef Jake ahead of the meal to see if he could accommodate. He swapped out the few meat dishes for some delicious seafood ones - including Maine Lobster, and he was so kind about it too. He can accommodate vegetarian, just not vegan. I've seen underground dining in Chicago specifically tailored to vegetarian cuisine as well as an option.
#4 Alba 2013-03-05 07:16
Oh, and one more question. As a vegetarian, are secret dinner menus pretty much out of the question?...
#3 Alba 2013-03-05 07:13
So, here's a question, if it's not rude. How much does a secret dinner cost one? It seems like the sort of thing you could only do once on a very special occasion. Is that fair to assume?
#2 Jessica Dixon 2013-03-04 18:19
@ Alan It's because I was at the head of the table and got served first. They look serious because they're plotting to get the kumquat I'm mocking them with.
+1 #1 Alan Rader 2013-03-04 15:37
Charming. Sounds deliciious. But why aren't the guys at the other table smiling? Anyhow, please put me on the mailing list. (Yes, I get that there's no mailing list.)

Comments have been closed for this piece.

 

restaurant news

Capogiro
Philadelphia
by Laura Johnson

gelatofruit.jpg Just recently my mother asked me to pick up some vanilla ice cream she wanted to serve with a pie she had made. I came home with a gallon of 'Pet' vanilla ice cream. She asked me why, out of all...

Read more...
A Taste of Italy at B and B Ristorante
Las Vegas
by Lisa Dinsmore

bnbVegas. Why'd it have to be Vegas? I happily avoided going there for about 8 years. No real point since I don't gamble. Might as well just burn your money, since you're not going to win. What else...

Read more...
Finding L'Astrance
Paris
by Alexander Lobrano

An excerpt from  "Hungry for Paris"

paris1.jpg Some ten years ago, I went to dinner one night with no expectations. A London newspaper had asked me to write about Lapérouse, an old warhorse of a...

Read more...
Hot? How About a Milkshake at Pono Burger?
Los Angeles
by Evan Kleiman

PonoStrawberry-MilkshakeOn this very hot day I can’t stop thinking about the strawberry milkshake I inhaled for dessert at Pono Burger a couple weeks back. Strawberry was all time childhood ice cream fave flavor.

But...

Read more...